Skip to content

Welcome to Bitesize!

Firehead has teamed up with its recruitment talent to launch a unique content strategy service, offering fast and cost-effective 'bitesize' audits for clients. Find out more today…

Subscribe me!

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

User Manuals: Demise or Morph?

Posted on May 28, 2010 by: Firehead

A good friend and colleague of mine, Theresa Cameron, International Representitive for the UK ISTC, sent me this article, “iPad: Manual not Included”,  from the Independent (UK) by Simon Usborne pondering the demise of the user manual. Usborne also interviews two other well known and repsected professionals in our field, whose opinons I repsect quite a lot: Ellis Pratt of Cherryleaf and Dr Mark Miodownik, an engineering lecturer at King’s College London.

I think this is fascinating stuff – it’s both historical and very modern. Why are new products shipping with no user manuals, when the technology in our gadgets is getting more and more complex by the day? And where does this leave the field of technical communications? Well. There’s quite a lot to say.

Not so long ago, you needed those instructions on the Quick Reference Guide just to assemble and install your new gadget and its software. But over time, manuals have evolved into dry, disclaimer-filled throw-aways compared to the glossy material that once came with our new purchases (and nobody read either). You’re now usually referred to the website for anything very useful. The old manual has pretty much disappeared – some say in the name of the trees, some say for cost savings, some because you only need to include the legal stuff to be on the right side of the law.

The iPad doesn’t come with instructions – and only a page of sort of sketchy outlines (if you can even call them that). The entire set of user directions that come with the packaging is printed on one side the page in two paragraphs and an annotated image showing the device’s buttons (all four of them) on the other. The famous simplicity of the Apple touch screen interface does pronounce “this is how to use me” to a first-time toucher, so what’s going on? Are we losing our curiosity about how technology works?

Is the manual dying or is it dead? If the phone in your pocket or the satnav on your windscreen needs an inch-thick manual, arguably it has failed. And, anyway, who needs a printed document when there’s Google? – a portal to more guidance and tutorials than could ever be squeezed into a black and white booklet.

But is a world without manuals so bright? Some in the technical communications field believe the manual is an art worth preserving. No surprise there, but what would we do without them?

As the paper manual has withered there are signs of life on the internet. Even the magicians at Apple provide online guides. Elsewhere, hundreds of websites and forums have sprung up with how-to video clips and pages of instructions.

Ellis Pratt explains that “People under 27 have never known life without the internet and so they behave differently when they get stuck. Even if there is a manual, you can put it in their hands and they’ll still go straight to Google.”

But what if you’re older than 27?

“When a senior colleague was recently convinced by his teenage children that he needed an iPhone, the shiny device sat in its shiny box for two days (“Sync it to iTunes? Can’t I just make a telephone call?”). On the third day, he took it to a shop where a “nice young man” (definitely under 27) sorted him out.”

Reaching for Google has become a relex for those raised in the IT world (the under 27s), but it’s not second nature to those who grew up without the Internet to run to to look up all of life’s questions. Some learn, some will always question.

Theresa Cameron  has traced the history of the manual to a 4th century BC Babylonian clay tablet that details a step-by-step “Guide to Inducing Dreams” – a user manual. Theresa asserts that the more things change, the more they stay the same. “The art in our job is to put ourselves in the position of the end user and translate engineer speak” she says. Nothing has fundamentally changed – except the medium used to convey the message. If we need to go to Google, a manual or a stone tablet, we’re always going to need someone to explain how to use the damn thing.

3 Responses to “User Manuals: Demise or Morph?”

  1. I guess the iPad is a little different being more of a consumption device rather than creation gadget. Although, let’s face it, there will always be people who need a manual in order to switch on a TV.

    I do agree with the shifting change in culture though – when stuck, the digitally included will go online for answers, with crowdsourced responses and support forums replacing the ‘official’ line of help.

  2. Jennifer O Neill says:

    The usability of devices is also continullay improving. User centric design is a major commercial driving force these days, making features more intuitive to use. Apple has been a leader in this for years. Often manuals were/are documenting the results of poorly designed products.

  3. Karen says:

    Then, of course, there is the world of manufacturing or special equipment. When people work in noisy, dirty, sterile, hot, cold – well, all sorts of different environments – they don’t always have access to Google or YouTube for information. They might require a laminated sheet of paper with clear/plain language instructions. They might require a printed manual because an electronic device won’t work. I think there are times when we make a lot of assumptions and generalizations about that demographic called “users”. That’s why I love Theresa’s closing quote: “The manual has changed, but it’s not dead.”


Leave a Reply